What’s The Difference Between First-Party And Third-Party Special Needs Trusts?

There are two primary types of special needs trusts: first-party and third-party, which are designed to assist individuals with disabilities in preserving public benefits when there is additional money available. First-party SNTs utilize the beneficiary’s own assets, typically from a settlement or inheritance. Third-party special needs trusts hold money from somebody else, such as parents or family, and are not reimbursed to the state after the individual’s passing. Both help pay for expenses not covered by government programs, but they vary in who funds them, how they interact with public assistance, and what happens to the remaining funds.

Families navigating these decisions often benefit from working with an experienced special needs planning firm, such as Dyer Bregman & Ferris, PLLC, which focuses on aligning trust structures with long-term care goals and public benefit requirements. To assist individuals and families in selecting the appropriate trust, this blog provides concise information and straightforward guidance for each variety.

Key Takeaways

• Special needs trusts are important legal instruments that enable people with disabilities to accept additional financial assistance without jeopardizing access to government benefits like Medicaid and Supplemental Security Income.
• The primary difference between first-party and third-party special needs trusts is the funding source. First-party trusts are funded by the beneficiary’s assets, while third-party trusts are funded by others, often family or friends.
• First-party trusts must have a Medicaid payback provision, so any remaining trust assets are used to reimburse the government upon the beneficiary’s death. Third-party trusts allow assets to be disbursed as the trustor wishes.
• Establishment rules differ significantly. First-party trusts require the beneficiary to be under 65 years old at creation. Third-party trusts offer greater flexibility and can be established regardless of the beneficiary’s age.
• Deciding on the appropriate type of trust and trustee involves thoughtful reflection of legal necessities, estate planning objectives, and the beneficiary’s enduring needs. Expert advice from legal or financial professionals is advised.
• By combining special needs trusts with other planning vehicles like ABLE accounts and customized estate plans, families can maximize their support and safeguard the financial future of their loved ones with disabilities.

Understanding Special Needs Trusts

Special needs trusts (SNTs) are legal instruments that allow individuals with disabilities to retain vital government benefits, such as SSI and Medicaid, while receiving supplemental assistance from other sources. These trusts control assets for the SNT beneficiary and ensure funds are spent only on items that do not diminish their qualifications. Established to fund things that government assistance does not cover, such as additional care, lessons, travel, or therapy, these trusts directly pay those expenses. This arrangement allows beneficiaries to enjoy a higher quality of life without compromising their Medicaid benefits or cash assistance.

There are wide varieties of special needs trusts, with the two primary categories being first-party and third-party SNTs. A first-party SNT is funded with the individual’s own assets, such as proceeds from a personal injury settlement or inheritance, and must comply with specific government-mandated regulations to preserve benefits. Conversely, a third-party SNT is established by another person, usually a parent or grandparent, using their own funds or assets. Importantly, a third-party trust cannot include any money that belongs to the person with special needs, as this would jeopardize their government support. Moreover, third-party trusts do not have to fulfill Medicaid payback requirements upon the beneficiary’s death, offering a significant advantage over first-party trusts.

Pooled special needs trusts are available. These allow multiple individuals with disabilities to combine their assets under one trust, administered by a charitable organization. Everyone gets an account, and the trust leverages the power of a collective to lower fees and increase yield. This is a great arrangement, should the individual not have a family member to handle the trust.

When establishing a trust, it is crucial to avoid intermingling first- and third-party funds, maintain clear records of the origin of funds, and seek assistance from an estate planning attorney rather than relying on a DIY form. Each trust type has significant long-term implications for the safety and well-being of the SNT recipient, making meticulous planning and legal guidance essential.

Because special needs trusts are governed by a combination of federal regulations and state-specific rules, professional guidance is often essential. Attorneys at Dyer Bregman & Ferris, PLLC, regularly assist families with structuring first-party, third-party, and pooled special needs trusts in a way that protects benefit eligibility while addressing long-term planning goals. Proper drafting, clear funding sources, and thoughtful trustee selection can help prevent common mistakes that lead to benefit loss or unnecessary Medicaid payback exposure.

Feature	First-Party SNT	Third-Party SNT	Pooled SNT
Source of Funds	Beneficiary’s assets	Family/friends	Multiple beneficiaries
Medicaid Payback	Yes	No	Yes (varies)
Court Oversight	Sometimes required	Rarely required	Sometimes required
Can Mix Asset Types	Never	Never	Never

In summary, understanding how special needs trusts work is vital for ensuring that disabled beneficiaries can access both their trust funds and government benefits without jeopardizing their financial security. This careful approach to special needs planning can make a profound difference in the lives of individuals with disabilities.

First-Party Vs. Third-Party Trusts

Both first-party and third-party special needs trusts (SNTs) are designed to protect assets and provide for a disabled individual, but they do so in very different ways. The primary difference is who is funding it, which influences the terms, limitations, and advantages associated with each trust. Understanding these key considerations allows families to choose wisely for long-term financial security while ensuring access to vital government benefits.

1. The Funding Source

First-party trusts utilize the beneficiary’s personal funds. This could be a settlement, inheritance, or savings. For instance, if you are court-awarded post-accident, those funds can go into a first-party trust. The origin of the assets is controlled by the beneficiary, but not the trust’s terms.

Third-party trusts are funded by someone else. Mom, dad, grandparents, friends, or relatives can establish and contribute assets. The beneficiary cannot add their own stash. A third-party trust cannot receive an inheritance paid directly to the beneficiary or a settlement in their name.

Funding source affects government benefit qualification. First-party trusts enable you to be eligible for benefits like Medicaid even if you have assets. Third-party trusts hold assets separate from the beneficiary, so these do not count against benefit eligibility.

Families have to decide on a funding strategy based on where assets come from and what they want to accomplish. Blending the two trust types can trigger undesirable government payback!

2. Establishment Rules

First-party trusts follow strict legal rules. The beneficiary must be under 65, and the trust often needs court oversight, depending on the region. They need to be disabled. These rules can be complicated and vary by state.

Third-party trusts are more flexible. They can be established at any age, for any purpose, and the beneficiary does not need to be disabled at the time of funding. State law does still apply. You typically need legal assistance to make sure everything complies with all the regulations.

3. The Payback Provision

First-party trust has to pay Medicaid back for benefits the beneficiary was given after death. This is known as the payback provision. The government has the right to be reimbursed from any remaining trust property.

A third-party trust has no such requirement. When the beneficiary dies, the remaining funds flow to other relatives or selected beneficiaries. That’s a big difference in planning. The payback clause can eat into what’s left for heirs.

Families have to weigh whether retaining assets in the bloodline outweighs the potential of leveraging the beneficiary’s own money for their care.

4. Beneficiary Age

First-party trusts need to be established prior to the beneficiary reaching 65. This age limit is rigid and determines who can take advantage of this trust option.

Third-party trusts have no age limitation. Families can initiate them for kids, adults, or seniors. Early planning is wise because age can shut down possibilities.

5. Estate Impact

First-party trust assets are subject to Medicaid payback, so usually, there is not much left for heirs when the beneficiary passes away. This can reduce the family estate.

Third-party trusts sidestep payback, so assets may flow to others unfettered. This helps families keep wealth within the family and out of the government’s hands.

Good legal counsel is important, as estate laws are intricate and generally diverse.

Medicaid Eligibility And Asset Protection:

1. First-Party Trusts:

• Assets don’t count against Medicaid limits.
• Has to pay back Medicaid after death.
• Frequently require court supervision.

2. Third-Party Trusts:

• Assets do not factor into Medicaid limits.
• No Medicaid payback.
• Seldom requires court monitoring.

A Closer Look: First-Party Trusts

A first-party special needs trust (SNT) is designed for a disabled individual and is funded with that individual’s own assets. These trusts are typically established when someone experiences a significant windfall, such as a court-awarded injury settlement or an unexpected inheritance. Governed by the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (OBRA) of 1993, these trusts require the individual to be under 65 at the time of establishment, although state laws may vary this age limit. The assets placed into a first-party trust must always come from the disabled person; think of an insurance claim lump sum rather than a family friend’s generous gift.

First-party SNTs enable individuals to retain vital government benefits, such as SSI and Medicaid, even if their personal assets would typically disqualify them. The trust can cover expenses that government benefits don’t, including medical care, therapy, education, or even travel. A trustee, who can be a parent, grandparent, guardian, or court-appointed individual, oversees the funds. If the disabled individual is capable, they can even set up the trust themselves. For smaller amounts, a pooled SNT may be a more practical option, as these are managed by nonprofit organizations that pool money from multiple individuals, thereby reducing expenses and providing expert management.

There are certain trade-offs to consider. The most significant is the Medicaid payback requirement: if the beneficiary passes away, any remaining funds in the trust must be used to repay the state for Medicaid or similar benefits received. This limitation makes first-party trusts less adaptable for transferring wealth to descendants. It’s crucial to keep first-party and third-party trusts separate, as mixing them may lead the government to seek repayment from both sources. Careful planning and legal advice are essential to avoid costly mistakes.

Advantages	Disadvantages
Keeps public benefit access	Must repay the state after death
Covers extra needs	Strict legal requirements
Can use own assets	Not for wealth transfer to heirs
Options for setup	Age and funding restrictions

All families should take a close look at their specific needs and local laws to determine if a first-party trust is appropriate.

A Closer Look: Third-Party Trusts

As a main option for families who want to plan for a loved one with a disability, third-party special needs trusts exist. With these trusts, someone other than the disabled individual establishes and funds the trust, such as parents, grandparents, or other relatives. The funds or assets used to capitalize the trust, which are often referred to as trust funds, never belonged to the beneficiary, which is critical to how these trusts work and what regulations they follow.

One big advantage of a third-party trust is its versatility. The best part is that there is no age ceiling for the person with the disability, which differentiates it from first-party trusts that have to be established prior to the beneficiary turning 65. Families can plan at any time, regardless of whether the individual is a minor or an adult. The trust can house all sorts of assets, cash, stocks, real estate, or even life insurance proceeds. Because the money in the trust never belonged to the beneficiary, the government can’t come after the trust for Medicaid payback requirements once the person with the disability dies. Instead, the balance can go to other relatives or whoever the original donor designates, making it a powerful legacy-leaving mechanism.

These trusts are designed to play nice with government programs such as SSI and Medicaid. The trust covers expenses that government assistance doesn’t, like vacation, recreation, or specialized therapies. It prevents the beneficiary from losing access to critical government benefits and still provides them with an enhanced lifestyle. That’s because the trust assets are not considered the beneficiaries and therefore do not adversely impact means-tested resources.

These trusts are common when parents or grandparents wish to provide a gift, save funds, or leave an inheritance. A third-party trust cannot own any assets that ever belonged to the beneficiary. If a special needs individual receives an inheritance or settlement directly, that money needs to be put into a first-party or pooled trust, not a third-party trust.

For families seeking a savvy long-term plan, third-party trusts are worth a look for a special needs loved one. They provide control, security, and the ability to mold an enduring legacy while abiding by regulations that safeguard access to public assistance.

The Trustee’s Crucial Role

The trustee administers the assets within a special needs trust and ensures that the individual with special needs receives maximum assistance from them. The position carries significant responsibilities. The trustee has to understand the trust rules, the individual’s needs, and the applicable laws. They pay bills, purchase items for the individual, and monitor every step. They have to protect government benefits by not dispensing funds in a manner that would harm the individual’s support. A satisfying trustee cares about both the immediate requirements and the enduring protection of the trust. They maintain accounts, report to appropriate parties, and ensure the trust complies with regulations.

Choosing the right trustee is one of the most critical decisions. The individual or organization has to be truthful, prudent, and intelligent with finances. They have to know the special needs trust rules and should be familiar with what the person needs to have a quality lifestyle. A trustee who understands the law and the individual’s special needs can ensure that the trust continues to do good for years without a hitch. Occasionally, a relative is a good option because they know the individual well. In other instances, a professional or an institution may be preferable, particularly if the trust is large or the regulations are intricate.

Trustee options come with their own pluses and minuses:

1. Family Member Trustee:

• Pros: Knows the person well, can be more flexible, may cost less.
• Cons: May lack technical know-how, could face stress or conflicts.

2. Professional Trustee (Like A Lawyer Or Accountant):

• Pros: Has experience, knows the laws, and is used to handling money.
• Cons: May cost more, could feel less personal.

3. Corporate Trustee (Bank Or Trust Company):

• Pros: Has strict rules, stays in business over time, and knows how to manage big trusts.
• Cons: Can cost a lot, may seem cold or less flexible.

Families really need to look under the hood of every candidate. See what they understand, their experience, and their compatibility with him. The trustee’s critical responsibility is to prioritize the individual’s needs, secure assets, and remain lawful.

Strategic Trust Integration

Strategic trust integration is planning everything out for a special needs individual. It integrates various vehicles, special needs trusts, ABLE accounts, and letters of intent, so that each complements the other. It’s always about the individual’s needs, how the family functions, and what the long-term objectives are, not just about pinching pennies or adhering to regulations. There are three main trust types: first-party, third-party, and pooled trusts. They each have their advantages and constraints. Third-party trusts are unique because it’s family or friends funding them, rather than the special needs individual. These trusts excel in protecting government benefits and financial longevity. They can’t have any money owned by the special needs individual; this is the law. First-party trusts operate for those under 65 and need to reimburse the State upon the individual’s death. Third-party trusts don’t have this payback rule or an age cut-off, so they are more flexible for some families.

Smart planning is matching the kind of trust with what the individual requires now and will require eventually. When families intermingle first-party and third-party assets, all sorts of things can go wrong. The government can seek first-party assets once the individual dies. This could impact the third-party trust if it’s not properly managed. The SECURE Act altered the landscape for inheriting retirement funds and, by extension, how trusts are structured. Families should know these new rules and consider how assets like IRAs fit with their trust plans. Bringing in ABLE accounts or a letter of intent provides additional means to assist. An ABLE account allows the special needs individual to save some cash for day-to-day use, whereas a letter of intent can help communicate to others what the person enjoys and requires.

Working with the pros counts. Benefits of teaming up with legal, financial, and care experts include:

• Help picking the right trust for the situation
• Advice on keeping benefits while meeting care goals
• Guidance on new laws like the SECURE Act
• Support in updating plans as life changes

Families who plan and update their plans save themselves time, money, and frustration and get better outcomes for their loved ones with special needs.

Final Remarks

To clarify first-party versus third-party special needs trusts, it is essential to examine who funds the trust and the governing rules that control how it functions. A first-party trust is funded with the individual’s own money, such as settlements or inheritances, and allows them to remain eligible for public assistance. A third-party trust holds assets from family members or others and enables support without jeopardizing benefits.

Each trust requires careful planning, clear objectives, and a knowledgeable trustee. With guidance from an experienced firm like Dyer Bregman & Ferris, PLLC, families can develop a strategy that protects benefits, preserves assets, and supports the long-term well-being of their loved ones. Thoughtful special needs planning provides peace of mind and meaningful security for individuals with disabilities and the families who support them.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How Does A First-Party Special Needs Trust Work?

First-party vs. third-party special needs trusts: What’s the difference? A first-party SNT is often funded with an inheritance or legal settlement and must adhere to Medicaid payback requirements, including reimbursement to the state upon the beneficiary’s demise.

2. What Is A Third-Party Special Needs Trust?

A third-party SNT, or special needs trust, is funded by someone other than the beneficiary, such as parents, and does not require Medicaid payback after the beneficiary’s death.

3. Who Can Act As A Trustee For A Special Needs Trust?

It can be a trusted family member, friend, or even a professional. The trustee administers the trust assets, ensuring compliance with specific trust requirements, and distributes them for the beneficiary’s benefit without jeopardizing vital government benefits.

4. Why Is A Trustee Important In A Special Needs Trust?

The trustee ensures that the beneficiary’s needs are met while adhering to specific trust requirements, safeguarding vital government benefits, and extending funding effectively.

5. Can A Special Needs Trust Be Used Worldwide?

Special needs trusts, vital government benefits in the US, are founded on laws that can vary by state. These trusts may not be relevant elsewhere.

Special Needs Planning In Arizona: Protect The People Who Matter Most With DBF Legal On Your Side

Planning for a loved one with special needs brings unique legal and financial challenges. In Arizona, the rules around benefits, trusts, and long-term care are detailed, and one misstep can put critical SSI or Medicaid eligibility at risk. Families often feel overwhelmed trying to balance protection, flexibility, and peace of mind. That’s where DBF Legal steps in.

At DBF Legal, special needs planning isn’t just about documents; it’s about safeguarding a future. Our team helps Arizona families create thoughtful, legally sound plans that protect government benefits while providing real support and stability for the years ahead. From special needs trusts and trustee selection to coordination with life insurance and letters of intent, we focus on solutions that fit your family’s exact situation.

Arizona’s special needs planning laws can feel complex, but our experience and personalized approach make the process clear and manageable. Our attorneys are known for careful planning, practical guidance, and strong advocacy for families who want to do right by their loved ones without unnecessary risk or stress.

Don’t leave your family’s future to chance. Contact DBF Legal today to start special needs planning in Arizona with confidence. Your loved one’s security matters. Your peace of mind matters. We’re here to protect both.

Disclaimer 

The materials available on this website are for informational and educational purposes only and are not intended to provide legal or professional advice. You should consult with a qualified attorney for advice concerning any particular legal matter or situation. Do not act or refrain from acting based on any content included on this site without seeking appropriate legal counsel. The information presented on this website may not reflect the most current legal developments or laws. No action should be taken in reliance on the information provided on this website. We disclaim all liability for actions taken or not taken based on any or all of the contents of this site to the fullest extent permitted by law.